Trusted By Over 250,000 Customers!
No Interest, No Payments for 12 months on Select Products
No Interest, No Payments for 12 months on Select Products
When planning a bathroom remodel, choosing the right bathtub material is more important than many homeowners realize. Your tub isn’t just a center‑piece; it’s used daily, and its material affects comfort, durability, appearance, and upkeep. Two of the most common options are acrylic and fiberglass. At first glance they seem similar, but their long‑term performance is quite different.
This guide will walk through the differences between acrylic and fiberglass tubs—covering performance, maintenance, cost, and durability—so you can make the best choice for your remodel. We’ve also included a helpful FAQ at the end to answer your frequently asked questions. If you need additional help, Renuity is always happy to discuss your options when it comes to walk-in baths and other quality KOHLER products.
The tub’s material determines how long it lasts, how warm it feels, and how easy it is to keep clean. No one wants to replace a cracked or stained tub only a few years after remodeling, so understanding the strengths and weaknesses of each material is key to a remodel that truly lasts.
Acrylic tubs are molded from sheets of acrylic, then reinforced with fiberglass for strength. The exposed surface is a high‑gloss acrylic skin that’s low‑porous and easy to wipe clean.
For homeowners who want long‑term durability with minimal upkeep, acrylic is a dependable, mid‑priced choice.
Fiberglass tubs are formed by spraying fiberglass‑resin into a mold, then coating the shell with a thin gelcoat finish. The gelcoat starts out smooth and water‑resistant, but as it wears the underlying fiberglass matrix can become more porous.
Fiberglass works well in low‑traffic bathrooms or rentals where budget is the top priority, but it rarely outlasts acrylic under daily use.
Bottom line: Acrylic costs a bit more at purchase but usually outperforms fiberglass over time, especially in busy households.
If longevity and low maintenance rank high on your remodel checklist, acrylic earns its slightly higher price tag.
Other materials—cast iron, enameled steel, stone resin, gelcoat composites—all have their niches, but they bring trade‑offs in cost, weight, or upkeep. For most modern remodels, acrylic strikes the best balance of durability, comfort, and affordability.
KOHLER walk‑in baths use a multi‑layer composite shell engineered for strength and easy cleaning:
Because fiberglass is buried in the core and not exposed, it delivers strength without the maintenance downsides of a standard fiberglass tub. The result is a walk‑in bath that pairs fiberglass reinforcement with an easy‑clean, glossy surface that retains heat and resists everyday wear. With innovative construction and a multitude of additional features and accessories, KOHLER walk-in baths offer a premium bathing experience that’s built to last.
Acrylic and fiberglass may look similar, but performance tells the real story. If you’re investing in a bathroom remodel you want to enjoy for years, acrylic offers superior durability, warmth, and low‑stress upkeep.
At Renuity, we install KOHLER walk‑in baths crafted with a reinforced composite shell and a glossy, easy‑clean finish designed for lasting comfort.
Ready to upgrade to a tub that truly lasts? Schedule your free consultation with Renuity today.
As a content manager at Renuity, Francheska spent nearly two years helping homeowners discover the possibilities of transforming their spaces. Renuity is a leader in home remodeling, specializing in everything from windows and doors to bathrooms and home storage solutions, and she’s proud to be part of a team that prioritizes quality, innovation, and customer satisfaction. She graduated from Florida International University with a double major in International Business and Marketing, ranked among the top programs in the nation. Her passion for home improvement runs deep—since childhood, she’s been inspired by watching HGTV and seeing the magic of remodels come to life. Now, she channels that passion into connecting readers with ideas, tips, and solutions to create homes they love.
Renuity is backed by top industry ratings and trusted by homeowners nationwide for quality, service, and reliability.
Offer expires:
plus 12 months, no interest, no or low monthly payments
claim offer
Get a free, no-obligation estimate and see how easy it is to upgrade to your dream home. One of our local specialists will reach out to schedule your consultation—on your terms.
At Renuity, our greatest pride comes from the trust homeowners place in us and the lasting results we deliver. From seamless installations to transformative home upgrades, we’re committed to making every project simple, stress-free, and built to last. Our family of regional brands includes some of the most respected names in remodeling nationwide, all united by proven expertise and a shared commitment to exceptional service. See how we’ve made a difference for families nationwide and what they have to say about their experiences with Renuity.
I would highly recommend the sales person, installers and the product itself! Another thing I really appreciated was how the whole team assigned to our project kept us totally informed or arrival time...
Renuity did an excellent job with my bathrooms. I highly recommend the entire experience from consultation to installation.
Mario provided excellent customer service when he came to replace the handle on our impact doors. He was very polite, professional, informative, and knowledgeable. He took the time to explain everythi...
Started out a little rough. The sales report did not get our full vision. Went into the office to cancel. The area manager Ashley-Bills Lagana fixed all our problems and areas of concern. Our bathroom...
Mike Post was very informative. He provided a great presentation of the products they offered. He listened to me to understand my needs and then met those needs.This was the first person I had come by...
Renuity isn’t the least expensive choice for a bath remodel, but their Kohler products and company work ethic are worth every penny. It was very easy to review my choices and set up a plan that fit my...
I don't have before pictures, but there was a 1970's plastic party tub!!!. No shower. Replaced it with a Kohler shower. Absolutely love it!!!. The salesperson was amazing. The install took 2 days. We...
Can't say enough good things about how an amazing job they did. Not only did I have them do my garage floor but they also provided a service to paint my entire garage that was unfinished. Very flexibl...
Maikel and Marcos have been wonderful, very efficient, and friendly. I'd recommend them to anyone that needs window installation. I also would like to mention John, the consultant at the Benjamin Rd....
We are very pleased with our Renuity cabinet refacing project. The finished cabinets look beautiful, and the team worked hard to ensure everything was completed to our satisfaction, resulting in a gre...
